HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: Get Your Equity, Keep Your First Mortgage
If you own a home and want to tap your equity, you've probably asked which is better, a HELOC or a home equity loan. For most homeowners I work with, the answer is a HELOC. You only pay on what you use, and your first mortgage stays exactly where it is.
A home equity loan is the better pick in two cases: you know the exact amount you need, or you're paying off a HELOC you've already drawn all the way down.
Here's how I decide, starting with the first question I ask every borrower.
HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: What's the Difference?
People use these two names like they mean the same thing. They don't.
- Home equity loan: you get one lump sum up front and pay it back on a set schedule. You pay interest on the whole amount from day one.
- HELOC (home equity line of credit): you get a line you can draw from when you need it. You only pay on what you've actually drawn.
If you have a mortgage, both of these sit behind it. Neither one touches it.
The First Question I Ask: Do You Owe Anything on the House?
Before we talk about what the money is for, I ask what you owe on the property and what your rate is.
If you have a low rate on your first mortgage, a HELOC almost always makes the most sense. A cash-out refinance replaces your entire first mortgage with a new loan at today's rates. A HELOC leaves your first mortgage alone.
I hear the same thing on almost every call. People want to get to their equity, but they don't want to refinance their first mortgage. They don't have to.
Why I Usually Recommend a HELOC
You Only Pay on What You Use
Say you're approved for a $100,000 line and you draw $30,000 for a kitchen. You pay on the $30,000. The other $70,000 sits there until you need it, and you're not paying interest on money you haven't touched.
With a home equity loan, you'd take the full amount on day one and pay interest on all of it, whether you've spent it or not.
You Keep Money Available for Later
Most of my clients use a HELOC for one of two things: home renovations or paying off debt. Almost all of them also want some of the line left open for later.
A HELOC can do that and a home equity loan can't. Once you've spent a home equity loan, getting more means applying for a new loan.
The Rate Only Applies to the HELOC
Some borrowers push back on the HELOC rate at first. Then they see that the rate only applies to the HELOC balance, not their whole mortgage, and that they can refinance the HELOC later without ever touching their first mortgage. Once they understand that, they're happy with it.
When a Home Equity Loan Is the Better Pick
I don't recommend a HELOC to everyone. A home equity loan wins in two situations.
You Know Exactly How Much You Need
Say you have one number and need all of it on day one, like a contractor bid you're paying in full. The flexibility of a line doesn't help you there. A lump sum on a set payment schedule fits better.
You've Already Drawn Your HELOC All the Way Down
If you've used the full line and you're just paying it back, you're not using the flexibility anymore. Refinancing that balance into a home equity loan gives you one set amount to pay down on a set schedule.
What I Warn People About With a HELOC
The Rate Can Go Up
Most HELOCs have a variable rate, so your rate can rise over time. That's the biggest worry I hear.
Not every HELOC is variable, though. Some of the HELOC programs I have access to offer a fixed rate, depending on the program. If a rising rate is what worries you, ask about a fixed option before you rule out a HELOC.
Ask About Early Closure Fees
If you plan to pay off or refinance the HELOC down the road, ask whether your program charges a fee for closing the line early. Some do. Know before you sign.
How to Qualify for a HELOC and How Fast It Can Close
Most people expect a long, painful process. On the programs I use, it doesn't have to be.
- Speed: I can qualify and fund a HELOC in as little as 5 business days.
- No pay stubs, W-2s or tax returns on the fast route: you connect your bank account through Plaid, and it verifies your monthly deposits automatically. This works whether you're employed or self-employed.
- Credit score: you need a 680 credit score or higher to use the bank-connection route.
- The other route: you can document your income with tax returns instead. Most self-employed borrowers would rather skip that, and on the bank-connection route they can.
So Which One Should You Pick?
Pick a HELOC if:
- You have a low rate on your first mortgage and want to keep it
- You'll spend the money over time, like a renovation done in stages
- You want money left available for later
Pick a home equity loan if:
- You know the exact amount and need all of it up front
- You're paying off a HELOC you've already drawn all the way down
If you're not sure, start with the question I'd ask you first: what do you owe on your house, and what's your rate? Start here and I'll tell you which one fits.
Alex D’Hose, NMLS #2705406 | West Capital Lending, NMLS #1566096 | Equal Housing Opportunity